WEBVTT 00:00:00.000 --> 00:00:09.920 What is the Cambridge content and bringing it across? 00:00:10.260 --> 00:00:13.980 There are not many Cambridge teachers in South Africa. 00:00:14.540 --> 00:00:16.000 Our networking is a problem. 00:00:16.400 --> 00:00:23.480 We do enjoy the discussion group, but we do sort of teacher training is significant. 00:00:23.480 --> 00:00:27.240 We value the face-to-face training. 00:00:27.380 --> 00:00:28.780 We value the online training. 00:00:28.780 --> 00:00:30.780 but that is a problem. 00:00:32.920 --> 00:00:36.940 I think that's pretty well, I don't think I've left anything else, 00:00:37.020 --> 00:00:38.760 I think that pretty well covers us. Thank you. 00:00:39.420 --> 00:00:41.520 Thank you very much and welcome South Africa. 00:00:42.200 --> 00:00:45.740 I think we're going to touch on all of those subjects as we go through the day. 00:00:46.780 --> 00:00:50.360 Now the concept of Cambridge mathematics was championed by Simon Liebus, 00:00:50.500 --> 00:00:53.180 the Chief Executive of Cambridge Assessment in late 2013. 00:00:54.320 --> 00:00:57.660 Collaboration with the four departments of the university most nearly concerned 00:00:57.660 --> 00:01:00.780 with improving mathematics education worldwide followed 00:01:00.780 --> 00:01:04.660 and the Cambridge Mathematics was formalised in November 2014. 00:01:05.660 --> 00:01:08.460 Today sees the official launch of the consultation 00:01:08.460 --> 00:01:10.920 on the framework of that concept. 00:01:11.700 --> 00:01:15.560 This is the starting point for a five-year development programme 00:01:15.560 --> 00:01:18.400 which once complete will see the framework 00:01:18.400 --> 00:01:20.820 and Cambridge Mathematics linked to resources, 00:01:21.280 --> 00:01:23.440 professional development and lastly assessment. 00:01:24.260 --> 00:01:25.780 And because it's the starting point, 00:01:25.780 --> 00:01:31.260 We're looking to you, those who've spent their lives working with maths and with young people, 00:01:31.580 --> 00:01:42.089 to contribute your thoughts to each part of the process This is not a conference with question and answer sessions It is intended to be a series of four genuine seminars 00:01:42.429 --> 00:01:44.289 each tackling part of the whole. 00:01:44.889 --> 00:01:48.089 So if you want to make a point, draw in some research, 00:01:48.529 --> 00:01:50.489 challenge another speaker in the audience, 00:01:50.909 --> 00:01:54.029 put across your experience rather than ask questions, 00:01:54.029 --> 00:01:55.689 I encourage you to do so. 00:01:56.249 --> 00:02:00.009 It's only from the clash of ideas coming from you, not us, 00:02:00.009 --> 00:02:05.329 coupled with serious underlying research that any of us can possibly make progress in this matter. 00:02:06.109 --> 00:02:10.389 So you should also know that all the chairs for today will be proactive. 00:02:11.069 --> 00:02:17.289 That is, they will be looking for signs of assent and dissent and asking you to voice that. 00:02:17.969 --> 00:02:23.849 Most of you are well known in the field and have papers, books and speeches in the subject to your name 00:02:23.849 --> 00:02:28.549 and we may be asking you for your views regardless of whether you've raised your hand or not. 00:02:28.549 --> 00:02:33.009 So I urge you to pitch in and let the maths community have your thoughts. 00:02:33.709 --> 00:02:41.329 So with that in mind, let's start with a short video which provides a view of Cambridge Mathematics as seen by its initial proponents. 00:02:46.429 --> 00:02:49.469 It's a really interesting time for mathematics education. 00:02:49.789 --> 00:02:55.029 We're in a position now where we really don't know what students of today are going to have to do in the future. 00:02:55.029 --> 00:02:59.829 So the aim of this fantastic new initiative called Cambridge Mathematics is to champion 00:02:59.829 --> 00:03:04.389 and to secure quality mathematics education for all students. 00:03:04.389 --> 00:03:09.209 I hope we'd have a framework that we've got general consensus on and then we would start 00:03:09.209 --> 00:03:13.549 populating that with assessments and resources and a professional 00:03:13.656 --> 00:03:17.656 development offer that would support that framework. 00:03:17.656 --> 00:03:21.936 Cambridge Mathematics is a really important initiative. It's bringing together different 00:03:21.936 --> 00:03:27.616 parts of the university and the skill sets that are within the university. So UCR and 00:03:27.616 --> 00:03:31.976 Cambridge International on the assessment side part of Cambridge assessment, Cambridge 00:03:31.976 --> 00:03:37.176 University Press on the resources and development side, the education department and then Rich 00:03:37.176 --> 00:03:42.176 on supporting the teacher and developing the teacher and then the maths departments, the 00:03:42.176 --> 00:03:45.896 understanding of maths and how that can be applied in all sorts of different 00:03:45.896 --> 00:03:51.236 scenarios. In the past we've known about each other's work but we haven't worked 00:03:51.236 --> 00:03:54.296 together and collaborated and this project gives us an opportunity to 00:03:54.296 --> 00:03:59.516 collaborate. Maths is always high on the political agenda and even though maths 00:03:59.516 --> 00:04:03.776 participation in post-16 is actually quite low compared to the rest of the 00:04:03.776 --> 00:04:08.036 world it's becoming more and more important as people are realising the 00:04:08.036 --> 00:04:13.096 utility of maths in the workplace. There's increasing government focus on the teaching 00:04:13.096 --> 00:04:20.676 of mathematics and where maths students end up and so we feel very strongly that the authority 00:04:20.676 --> 00:04:26.336 Cambridge can bring to that debate and the quality that the University of Cambridge is well known for 00:04:26.336 --> 00:04:34.516 will mean that anybody anywhere in the world will have access to a really coherent, well-organised 00:04:34.516 --> 00:04:35.516 approach to mathematics. 00:04:35.516 --> 00:04:41.296 We're going through the, really the second industrial revolution, but this one's driven 00:04:41.296 --> 00:04:43.716 by data and by information. 00:04:43.716 --> 00:04:56.825 I think we have a chance to make an even bigger impact by combining the kind of understanding of mathematics and of the learning process with the opportunities that new approaches to learning content particularly through the 00:04:56.825 --> 00:05:02.265 use of technology, can do, whether that's in tracking the data on individual users to 00:05:02.265 --> 00:05:08.265 give a more personalised experience or using things like video game techniques in order 00:05:08.265 --> 00:05:11.465 to get people really engaged and excited about what they're doing. 00:05:11.465 --> 00:05:17.425 If you as a person can't understand and interpret the absolute wealth of data that comes your 00:05:17.425 --> 00:05:22.245 way just in order to be able to function in everyday life, then really you are very, very 00:05:22.245 --> 00:05:25.025 disenfranchised from taking part in society. 00:05:25.025 --> 00:05:29.785 I think the biggest challenge for maths education is supporting teachers. If you're asking them 00:05:29.785 --> 00:05:34.185 to move away from tried and tested methodologies that they're comfortable with to a more problem 00:05:34.185 --> 00:05:39.425 solving pedagogy, you're going to have to support them and bring them along with you. 00:05:39.425 --> 00:05:44.465 And part of that is actually asking teachers to work with you to develop these resources. 00:05:44.465 --> 00:05:48.765 Teachers in classrooms, to give them the resources, the ability to have that continued professional 00:05:48.765 --> 00:05:53.505 development to support them, to produce the lessons that they want to teach to their pupils 00:05:53.505 --> 00:05:56.845 and have them have the enjoyment out of teaching mathematics. 00:05:56.845 --> 00:06:02.225 I think if you have a framework that supports you through assessments and your own professional 00:06:02.225 --> 00:06:06.265 development, that's a very useful thing. 00:06:06.265 --> 00:06:11.485 This is genuinely about inviting people in to a conversation about what the future of 00:06:11.485 --> 00:06:14.625 mathematics education might look like. 00:06:14.625 --> 00:06:19.885 We want to engage the international as well as the national community. 00:06:19.885 --> 00:06:24.105 It's much easier to do that now, now that we've got the facility for digital communication 00:06:24.105 --> 00:06:25.105 etc. 00:06:25.105 --> 00:06:27.205 So it really can be a global debate. 00:06:27.311 --> 00:06:36.731 So we've got a space in which to look at mathematics curricula and decide what is really, really important about a quality maths education. 00:06:36.731 --> 00:06:46.751 We know more about the research, about how children learn and what are effective methods of teaching, how children can learn independently as well as being taught. 00:06:46.751 --> 00:06:52.351 so all of those things means that now it's a really ripe time for us to have this debate 00:06:52.351 --> 00:06:57.471 and it's a really ripe time to develop a framework which brings everything all together. 00:07:02.271 --> 00:07:06.831 That's the context ladies and gentlemen and now I'd like to introduce you to Professor 00:07:06.831 --> 00:07:11.071 Selesek Boryshevich, Vice-Chancellor of the University of Cambridge to open the conference. 00:07:11.851 --> 00:07:15.991 Unfortunately it appears that running a world-class university is more difficult than it looks 00:07:15.991 --> 00:07:18.291 and he's unable to join us live. 00:07:18.691 --> 00:07:21.051 However, he did make himself available for interview 00:07:21.051 --> 00:07:22.151 ahead of the conference 00:07:22.151 --> 00:07:25.671 to talk about the potential importance of Cambridge Mathematics. 00:07:35.411 --> 00:07:37.451 Vice-Chancellor, thank you very much indeed 00:07:37.451 --> 00:07:39.831 for talking to Cambridge Mathematics today. 00:07:40.391 --> 00:07:41.711 What's this event about? 00:07:43.031 --> 00:07:44.931 Well, the Cambridge Mathematics event 00:07:44.931 --> 00:07:50.691 is actually about launching a framework. It's about launching a framework which is held jointly 00:07:50.691 --> 00:07:55.251 between the Cambridge Mathematics Faculty, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge Assessment 00:07:55.251 --> 00:08:13.920 and the Faculty of Education And what we about is actually trying to understand all of the needs and the academic basis on which mathematics education from 5 to 19 should be put together as a holistic approach And this isn just of interest to academics in 00:08:13.920 --> 00:08:19.620 terms of deciding what's there. The long-term aim is to make sure that this is relevant to both 00:08:19.620 --> 00:08:25.520 students and to teachers so that the pedagogy is also taken on board at the same time. 00:08:25.520 --> 00:08:27.340 So why are you doing this now? 00:08:28.300 --> 00:08:32.280 Well, the biggest surprise is why it hasn't been done up until now. 00:08:32.500 --> 00:08:37.000 And in today's world, particularly in a world which is going to rely more and more on technology, 00:08:37.520 --> 00:08:43.780 then the acquisition of mathematical skills from 5 to 19 is a vital part of education. 00:08:44.300 --> 00:08:47.480 So it couldn't be more timely than at present. 00:08:47.700 --> 00:08:50.700 How does this differ from other programmes and visions? 00:08:51.280 --> 00:08:55.000 Well, Cambridge tries to make a difference in all that we do, 00:08:55.000 --> 00:09:01.080 but actually this above all else is trying to make sure that we provide the right sort of framework, 00:09:01.220 --> 00:09:06.560 the evidence base on which we can actually work, not just in the United Kingdom but globally, 00:09:06.980 --> 00:09:11.760 to see what do we know about mathematics education, where do we know about good practice, 00:09:12.120 --> 00:09:14.900 what do we know that works, what do we know that doesn't work, 00:09:15.160 --> 00:09:20.580 so that we can really build on that evidence base the best education system possible for young people. 00:09:20.940 --> 00:09:24.320 And do you think it's important to have a framework that is evidence-based? 00:09:24.320 --> 00:09:27.080 Well, it's something unique that Cambridge Mathematics does. 00:09:27.080 --> 00:09:32.320 I mean, we pride ourselves here at the university that virtually everything that we do, we try 00:09:32.320 --> 00:09:36.200 to do from an evidence base that's as strong as possible. 00:09:36.200 --> 00:09:40.840 So that we don't have to go around listening to anecdote after anecdote about what works 00:09:40.967 --> 00:09:46.747 But let's test as to what we know, understand where the gaps are, fill those gaps in, 00:09:47.027 --> 00:09:52.567 and then making sure that that evidence base can really inform the actions that follow on from that. 00:09:52.987 --> 00:09:55.227 I mean, mathematics is the most logical of subjects, 00:09:55.567 --> 00:10:00.407 so surely it is absolutely appropriate that we work with an evidence base first and foremost. 00:10:00.867 --> 00:10:04.487 And so how does this differ from other programmes or visions? 00:10:04.647 --> 00:10:07.267 You say mathematics is a logical discipline. 00:10:07.847 --> 00:10:12.347 Well, for me, mathematics is absolutely fundamental to the world of tomorrow. 00:10:12.887 --> 00:10:20.327 And therefore we owe it to our young people to make sure that they're provided with the best tools possible to actually deliver. 00:10:20.667 --> 00:10:25.507 And to help teachers be able to get the very best out of their students. 00:10:25.507 --> 00:10:34.027 And I suppose by involving all of these groups, all of these stakeholders and people, it's holistic in the way you're tackling it. 00:10:34.027 --> 00:10:38.547 Well, holistic it certainly is, and it's going to be even more holistic. 00:10:38.667 --> 00:10:42.847 While we start with the beginnings of a framework that we know from the four main players, 00:10:43.347 --> 00:10:48.447 this isn't just about ourselves, it's about engaging the whole mathematics community, 00:10:48.827 --> 00:10:52.707 not just here in Cambridge, but around the United Kingdom and overseas, 00:10:53.107 --> 00:11:01.747 so that we can begin to develop the right framework on which to base logical conclusions and best practice. 00:11:01.747 --> 00:11:11.747 You seem, Vice-Chancellor, to be mapping out a vision that's going to be a conversation about mathematics around the world. 00:11:11.947 --> 00:11:25.596 So how will it develop Well the one thing that I think we got to be very careful of is conversations can sometimes drift into and disappear into nothingness This is a conversation but with a very firm 00:11:25.596 --> 00:11:32.676 end goal, which is practical attainment and the best practical advice to deliver at the end of 00:11:32.676 --> 00:11:38.816 the day, the best sort of coursework, the best sort of material that's available online, the best 00:11:38.816 --> 00:11:43.556 support that we can to teachers, the best impact we can make on teacher education in mathematics. 00:11:44.096 --> 00:11:48.636 So yes, it's a conversation, but it's very much a conversation with an end goal. 00:11:49.196 --> 00:11:54.496 And why the University of Cambridge? You've got some famous and big names in mathematics, 00:11:54.696 --> 00:11:57.756 both at the current time and in your own history. 00:11:57.756 --> 00:12:03.696 Well, absolutely. I mean, I'm sorry, I'm going to be a little bit parochial here, but for me, 00:12:04.076 --> 00:12:08.736 Cambridge and mathematics are synonymous. If we go back from Isaac Newton to Stephen 00:12:08.736 --> 00:12:15.296 Hawking. These are just names that are day-to-day names. Mathematics isn't just 00:12:15.296 --> 00:12:19.836 about mathematicians sitting in mathematics departments. Engineers rely 00:12:19.836 --> 00:12:25.536 on mathematics. Biologists are increasingly relying on mathematics. And 00:12:25.536 --> 00:12:32.136 everybody who's working in today's world from computer scientists to the person 00:12:32.136 --> 00:12:35.676 who might be mending your washing machine increasingly has to have 00:12:35.676 --> 00:12:40.776 mathematical skills and part and parcel of their world. 00:12:40.776 --> 00:12:49.556 So this is an exciting program because it's got the foundations to set people off of all ages on a mathematical journey. 00:12:49.556 --> 00:12:54.516 Well it does and one of the real difficulties is we often talk about this framework 00:12:54.623 --> 00:12:59.323 oh, it's boring, it's yet another academic action. 00:12:59.883 --> 00:13:04.403 Why I think this one is different is because it set itself goals for the future. 00:13:05.003 --> 00:13:08.483 There are deliverables at the end of these discussions and these debates, 00:13:08.843 --> 00:13:11.863 and that's what I find exciting, because we know there will be an outcome, 00:13:11.863 --> 00:13:15.863 and we know that that outcome can make a real difference to students. 00:13:16.723 --> 00:13:21.763 It's not that I would see every single child as a potential Einstein or another Newton. 00:13:21.903 --> 00:13:23.063 That isn't going to happen. 00:13:23.063 --> 00:13:31.823 but what we can do is to build up the level of competence in mathematical skills that that individual student requires. 00:13:32.403 --> 00:13:39.083 And as with all things in education, all you aspire to do is to make sure that you can ensure that every single student 00:13:39.083 --> 00:13:43.943 can reach the highest level of performance that is commensurate with their abilities. 00:13:44.383 --> 00:13:50.283 That's the goal of education and yes, there'll be some wonderful mathematicians in the next decade that will come through, 00:13:50.283 --> 00:13:54.963 hopefully many of them coming through the university here in Cambridge, but many will not. 00:13:55.323 --> 00:13:59.923 But what I do hope is the work that the university is putting into this today 00:13:59.923 --> 00:14:05.543 will help all those people in the future, wherever their own careers and needs take them. 00:14:05.963 --> 00:14:10.423 Vice-Chancellor, thank you very much indeed for talking to Cambridge Mathematics today. 00:14:14.263 --> 00:14:17.323 It only remains for me to introduce our first speaker. 00:14:17.323 --> 00:14:22.023 she chaired the teams which attempted to advise ministers on the content of the new english 00:14:22.023 --> 00:14:39.052 national curriculum and associated assessments she has a first degree in psychology a pgce an ma and a dip math ed naturally she a certified math teacher and an invited fellow of the IMA and the ISDDE She is delighted to be the current president of the Mathematical 00:14:39.052 --> 00:14:45.212 Association. Lynn McClure is the first director of Cambridge Mathematics, coming to it from being 00:14:45.212 --> 00:14:52.112 the director of the prestigious Enrich Project. Since her appointment in November 2014, she has 00:14:52.112 --> 00:14:57.252 worked with the governance group to define a manifesto and created the first draft of the 00:14:57.252 --> 00:15:03.912 Cambridge Mathematics Framework. Further drafts of that framework rely on you and your continuing 00:15:03.912 --> 00:15:09.852 engagement. But to start with, we'll have her tell us exactly what she's aiming to do. Lynn. 00:15:09.852 --> 00:15:24.052 Thank you very much Bennett and may I add my welcome to all of you. 00:15:24.052 --> 00:15:30.972 It's really very pleasant and slightly daunting to have so many people in the audience that I know personally 00:15:30.972 --> 00:15:33.252 and whom I have a great deal of respect for. 00:15:33.252 --> 00:15:40.192 so to colleagues within the university to colleagues within the UK and to Egypt and South 00:15:40.192 --> 00:15:48.512 Africa welcome you heard from the VC that this is a an aspirational and we hope inspirational 00:15:48.512 --> 00:15:54.552 program and I feel very privileged to be in this position I should say that many people think that 00:15:54.552 --> 00:15:59.832 I probably ought to be certified but it's not a certified maths teacher I'm actually a chartered 00:15:59.832 --> 00:16:04.332 maths teacher and hopefully there is a bit of a difference between the two. 00:16:04.332 --> 00:16:08.152 Frameworks however of course come and go. 00:16:08.278 --> 00:16:15.558 have been lots and lots of different frameworks, so what is different about this? I think it's 00:16:15.558 --> 00:16:22.838 an amazing opportunity to take time to reflect and to have the resources of the university 00:16:22.838 --> 00:16:28.578 in order to take time to produce something which is not at the whim of political expediency. 00:16:29.318 --> 00:16:33.918 And I think that that's something that I'm sure is true across the world, but seems to 00:16:33.918 --> 00:16:36.458 may be particularly true of the UK. 00:16:37.918 --> 00:16:41.338 So, 15 minutes I've got. 00:16:42.358 --> 00:16:45.698 Otherwise, Bennett will have my guts for garters. 00:16:46.438 --> 00:16:49.918 But what is the mathematics framework, 00:16:50.058 --> 00:16:51.678 the Cambridge Mathematics Framework? 00:16:52.478 --> 00:16:54.078 Well, let's start with something tangible. 00:16:54.238 --> 00:16:57.378 Let's start with the document that you have in your pack, 00:16:57.858 --> 00:17:00.338 which, of course, I didn't give you before today 00:17:00.338 --> 00:17:02.478 because I didn't want you to have a chance to plan 00:17:02.478 --> 00:17:04.258 all the questions that you were going to ask. 00:17:04.978 --> 00:17:07.458 But it is a mapping. 00:17:08.858 --> 00:17:14.038 It's a multidimensional mapping of mathematics from 5 to 19. 00:17:15.938 --> 00:17:18.398 It's more than content, though, 00:17:18.718 --> 00:17:20.798 and as I talk this 15 minutes, 00:17:20.878 --> 00:17:22.798 I hope I'll encourage you to realise 00:17:22.798 --> 00:17:25.858 that actually content is possibly in some ways 00:17:25.858 --> 00:17:27.998 the least important part of it. 00:17:28.898 --> 00:17:31.818 This is what it looked like when we first started planning, 00:17:32.238 --> 00:17:37.358 Hopefully it looks a little bit more refined now. And in fact, the purpose of today is to 00:17:37.358 --> 00:17:53.047 start that process of rethinking reformulating and refining what the Cambridge Maths Framework might look like So what is it Well it is an organising structure and that what it for 00:17:53.427 --> 00:17:59.607 And it's an organising structure which is the spine of these four different elements 00:17:59.607 --> 00:18:04.127 which are going to make up the whole Cambridge Maths initiative. 00:18:05.647 --> 00:18:09.827 So curriculum, resources, professional development and assessment, 00:18:10.127 --> 00:18:13.087 in an integrated and coherent programme. 00:18:13.947 --> 00:18:17.427 The framework itself is actually written with assessment in mind. 00:18:17.787 --> 00:18:20.027 We have to take something as a focus to start with, 00:18:20.087 --> 00:18:22.167 and I'll come back again to that afterwards. 00:18:22.907 --> 00:18:26.147 But we want to make it integrated and we want to make it coherent. 00:18:26.347 --> 00:18:29.387 We want to make each of the elements of Cambridge maths 00:18:29.387 --> 00:18:33.087 a coherent and integrated process itself. 00:18:33.287 --> 00:18:35.247 We heard from South Africa, for example, 00:18:35.387 --> 00:18:38.367 how there seems to be a disconnect between some of the assessments. 00:18:38.367 --> 00:18:45.427 So we want things to be coherent within the elements, but we also want all of the elements to be coherent too. 00:18:47.867 --> 00:18:48.787 Why now? 00:18:49.187 --> 00:18:52.127 It was interesting when I was briefing the Vice-Chancellor that he said, 00:18:52.427 --> 00:18:54.967 why is it going to take you as long as five years? 00:18:55.887 --> 00:19:01.987 To which my response was, five years actually doesn't seem that long for such a major, major project. 00:19:01.987 --> 00:19:03.907 five years 00:19:03.907 --> 00:19:06.847 five years space is just about right 00:19:06.847 --> 00:19:08.707 to have a really good start 00:19:08.707 --> 00:19:09.947 to this project 00:19:09.947 --> 00:19:12.827 we know that there is an appetite 00:19:12.827 --> 00:19:14.387 to do something significant 00:19:14.387 --> 00:19:16.667 and so I suppose the comment 00:19:16.667 --> 00:19:18.947 really is not why now 00:19:18.947 --> 00:19:20.507 but why not now 00:19:21.934 --> 00:19:33.774 So why five years? Well, we have four guiding principles. And the first guiding principle 00:19:33.774 --> 00:19:40.214 is that wherever it is at all possible, we're going to base what we do on evidence and research. 00:19:41.614 --> 00:19:47.334 And so this will be a tangible outcome of getting to know what the research and the evidence 00:19:47.334 --> 00:19:53.794 space is. There's lots and lots of evidence and research done in education and in mathematics 00:19:53.794 --> 00:19:59.014 education. Quite often nothing actually comes of it. It's a learned paper. What we want to do is 00:19:59.014 --> 00:20:03.214 look at the research and the evidence and see what the therefore the results of that would be, 00:20:03.294 --> 00:20:10.174 what the implications of that would be. We want to make sure that we collaborate. Yes of course 00:20:10.174 --> 00:20:15.514 it's much easier now that we have new technology to collaborate through video, through Skype and 00:20:15.514 --> 00:20:21.794 all the rest of it but actually it takes time to talk to people and to listen to people when we 00:20:21.794 --> 00:20:26.814 talk about collaboration we don't mean just winning hearts and minds we actually mean listening to 00:20:26.814 --> 00:20:31.334 what other people have to say although there's a lot of expertise in the university of cambridge 00:20:31.334 --> 00:20:35.554 it's not only in the university of cambridge there's a lot of expertise both in the uk 00:20:35.554 --> 00:20:38.734 and internationally and we need to learn from that 00:20:38.734 --> 00:20:45.374 we want to make it integrated so that means that although we're starting with something which is to 00:20:45.374 --> 00:20:50.314 do with assessment we need to keep an eye on everything else at the same time and again there 00:20:50.314 --> 00:21:05.123 are natural rhythms for those and we need to make sure that we understand how everything feeds into everything else and lastly but definitely not least and in fact maybe really should be the first access for all 00:21:05.863 --> 00:21:07.763 So the Vice-Chancellor spoke about the fact 00:21:07.763 --> 00:21:10.543 this is not about getting more students into Cambridge. 00:21:11.103 --> 00:21:15.183 Cambridge's mission is to impact on the learning 00:21:15.183 --> 00:21:18.383 and have a social conscience really about learning 00:21:18.383 --> 00:21:20.043 and making learning better for everybody 00:21:20.043 --> 00:21:21.623 and more accessible for everybody. 00:21:21.623 --> 00:21:28.803 so what we want to do is to try to write a framework which helps students and learners 00:21:28.803 --> 00:21:34.203 across the world have access to a quality mathematics education at whatever level is 00:21:34.203 --> 00:21:42.243 appropriate so what content and for what purpose i said that this wasn't only a framework about 00:21:42.243 --> 00:21:48.363 content but i'll come back to that in a moment but actually what content do we have so you have an 00:21:48.363 --> 00:21:56.623 example in your packs of the sort of content that we think is appropriate but people have different 00:21:56.623 --> 00:22:03.123 views about what the content should be for any particular purpose education is there in order 00:22:03.123 --> 00:22:09.223 to promote the things and the values a society thinks are really important and there are different 00:22:09.223 --> 00:22:17.643 sorts of contexts in which those views can be seen so we've got we've got the back to basics view 00:22:17.643 --> 00:22:19.543 of mathematics education. 00:22:20.323 --> 00:22:23.643 I think we've got a bit of that going on at the moment in the UK 00:22:23.643 --> 00:22:25.363 where long division and long multiplication 00:22:25.363 --> 00:22:28.483 seem to have a very disproportionate position. 00:22:29.323 --> 00:22:32.563 That's a sort of an authoritarian type view 00:22:32.563 --> 00:22:34.943 of what mathematics education is. 00:22:36.590 --> 00:22:49.410 We've got the pragmatic technocrats, those who think that the purpose of mathematics education is to have a skilled workforce who can then work in industry. 00:22:51.210 --> 00:23:05.330 We've got the pure mathematicians who believe that mathematics is a pure set of knowledge and the job of mathematicians is to pass that very coherent set of knowledge on to the next generation. 00:23:05.590 --> 00:23:11.290 we've got the progressive view of mathematics education 00:23:11.290 --> 00:23:14.830 where learning mathematics is something that impacts 00:23:14.830 --> 00:23:18.190 on students' own creativity and their confidence 00:23:18.190 --> 00:23:22.090 a very child-centered view of what mathematics education is 00:23:22.090 --> 00:23:24.210 and then we've got 00:23:24.210 --> 00:23:27.210 the sense of mathematics education 00:23:27.210 --> 00:23:29.830 which is to produce a numerate citizen 00:23:29.830 --> 00:23:34.730 and that's a really good example of 00:23:34.730 --> 00:23:38.370 fish and chip shop wasn't particularly numerate. 00:23:39.430 --> 00:23:45.190 So we think that there is an overlap in the content of all of those, 00:23:45.490 --> 00:23:49.130 but if you just specify the content, that's actually not enough 00:23:49.130 --> 00:23:53.750 to really get the depths of all the different aims that you might have 00:23:53.750 --> 00:23:55.670 for mathematics education. 00:23:57.250 --> 00:23:59.250 So we need some more dimensions. 00:23:59.250 --> 00:24:03.390 is. Jeff Wake 00:24:03.390 --> 00:24:06.710 worked with me at the very beginning and we were looking at 00:24:06.710 --> 00:24:23.399 what is the way in which we might cut the content of mathematics and we thought well let start with PISA because there a lot of research gone into PISA Why shouldn we look at what going to be used in PISA 15 And we used those to start with and actually we found that they 00:24:23.399 --> 00:24:28.499 didn't really help, partly because they're to do with numeracy rather than mathematics. 00:24:29.419 --> 00:24:36.739 And so we then went back and went to something that I think most people think is pretty usual 00:24:36.739 --> 00:24:42.219 and pretty boring. So if you look at the way that we've cut the content, there's nothing really very 00:24:42.219 --> 00:24:46.899 radical about that. And one of the things that we would really like to take some time to explore and 00:24:46.899 --> 00:24:52.619 think about is, are there better ways of actually cutting the content? We know that mathematics is a 00:24:52.619 --> 00:24:58.259 network and everything is connected. We've indicated some connections in the framework by 00:24:58.259 --> 00:25:04.939 some italics, but really, is there a better way of doing that? We can think of mathematics in lots 00:25:04.939 --> 00:25:10.759 of different ways. This is one of the prototypes for CEMEP, the Cambridge Maths Education Project, 00:25:10.879 --> 00:25:16.459 which is based in the mathematics faculty, where mathematics is seen as a set of tube lines, 00:25:16.599 --> 00:25:22.939 interacting tube lines. Maybe a framework should have some elements of that, as well as these 00:25:22.939 --> 00:25:28.579 distinct things. Of course, we could do something much more radical. If you read the work of Paul 00:25:28.579 --> 00:25:33.879 Ernest, he talks about distinguishing between the capability of mathematics and the appreciation 00:25:33.879 --> 00:25:38.859 of mathematics. So maybe there's something about splitting up the content of mathematics 00:25:38.859 --> 00:25:44.499 into those things which are about capabilities and utility, the utility use, and then the 00:25:44.499 --> 00:25:49.119 appreciation of it, the big ideas, the history and the culture of mathematics. 00:25:49.245 --> 00:25:54.245 mathematics. That would be quite a radical way of thinking about cutting the content. 00:25:54.905 --> 00:26:00.285 Maybe we could need to explore that. So there's lots more to research to be done on that. 00:26:01.005 --> 00:26:06.085 What we've given you is an example of a framework that we've been working on, but we're by no means 00:26:06.085 --> 00:26:10.365 wedded to that, and we would really like your contributions to think about whether we could 00:26:10.365 --> 00:26:16.445 do something which is a great more improvement on that. Whatever we do, of course, is going to 00:26:16.445 --> 00:26:22.865 impact on the other elements of the framework. It's going to impact on assessment. It's going 00:26:22.865 --> 00:26:29.645 to impact on professional development and on resources. So we've cut the content in 00:26:29.645 --> 00:26:34.945 these different ways, but we need some way of marking how we progress through the content. 00:26:35.665 --> 00:26:39.965 And there are lots of different models of this. The model that we've chosen to use is 00:26:39.965 --> 00:26:45.545 to look at threshold tasks, i.e. those tasks that you would need to achieve in order to 00:26:45.545 --> 00:26:49.525 be well prepared to progress on to the next stage. 00:26:50.865 --> 00:26:54.805 We've also, because we think that that's not really rich enough, 00:26:54.805 --> 00:27:03.245 we've also put in some examples of where you might meet a concept for the first time. 00:27:03.345 --> 00:27:05.785 The Japanese are quite keen on this. 00:27:06.005 --> 00:27:08.425 It's indicating not when you acquire a concept, 00:27:08.545 --> 00:27:12.285 because it's very difficult to say when you've actually acquired a concept properly, 00:27:12.825 --> 00:27:14.885 but where you first meet a concept. 00:27:14.885 --> 00:27:17.125 and then that concept, you meet that concept 00:27:17.125 --> 00:27:18.825 through different sorts of context 00:27:18.825 --> 00:27:32.774 so that you refine your understanding of what that concept is We done stages That because we looked at the Common European Framework for Languages which uses three stages each of them split into two sub 00:27:33.954 --> 00:27:35.694 Is that the right thing to do? 00:27:35.894 --> 00:27:37.374 Most people seem to... 00:27:37.374 --> 00:27:41.714 You know, the time when students move from one stage in education to the next 00:27:41.714 --> 00:27:44.254 seems to be more or less the same across the world, 00:27:44.334 --> 00:27:45.414 give or take a little bit. 00:27:46.054 --> 00:27:47.774 But are stages the best thing? 00:27:47.854 --> 00:27:49.874 Would it be better to have a continuous progression? 00:27:49.874 --> 00:27:55.074 If you have a continuous progression, how do you know when you're going to assess and have some parity across assessment? 00:27:55.514 --> 00:27:59.154 There are all sorts of questions that we might come out with there. 00:27:59.914 --> 00:28:05.414 Still talking about content, there are different ways in which you can engage with content. 00:28:05.594 --> 00:28:07.874 There are different ways in which you can act upon content. 00:28:08.054 --> 00:28:11.134 So we want some sense of depth of understanding. 00:28:11.774 --> 00:28:18.534 So we've taken, starting from Skempt, we've taken Skempt's idea of instrumental, I know what to do. 00:28:18.534 --> 00:28:24.574 relational I know what to do and I know why I do it but we've added on at the end schematic I know 00:28:24.574 --> 00:28:30.934 what to do I know why I do it but I can relate it to other places in mathematics in which this has 00:28:30.934 --> 00:28:38.534 some synergies that's incredibly crude when you compare it to what awarding organizations for 00:28:38.534 --> 00:28:45.234 example do when they're looking at the processes associated with particular assessments but we can 00:28:45.234 --> 00:28:48.834 always refine things and we can always add in more content we're trying to look 00:28:48.834 --> 00:28:54.474 at a proof of concept here problem solving well there's a problem with 00:28:54.474 --> 00:28:58.854 problem solving nobody quite knows what problem solving is and anybody who comes 00:28:58.854 --> 00:29:02.794 up with some definition somebody else always comes up with an alternative but that's not 00:29:02.901 --> 00:29:08.561 going to stop us. We're going to have a go at looking what problem solving really is. 00:29:08.721 --> 00:29:12.761 Problem solving is at the heart of mathematics. It doesn't have to be the modelling sort of 00:29:12.761 --> 00:29:17.661 problem solving where we're looking at external context. It could be internal within mathematics 00:29:17.661 --> 00:29:23.881 itself. But we do need a dimension where we can look at what the processes are that are 00:29:23.881 --> 00:29:29.701 there in problem solving. I couldn't think how to illustrate problem solving, so I thought 00:29:29.701 --> 00:29:33.201 Bob the Builder, can we solve it? Yes, we can. Might be a good one. 00:29:34.601 --> 00:29:39.161 So the first set of questions, and the ones that I hope that you will engage with, 00:29:39.161 --> 00:29:45.761 are what in this framework is worth keeping and what in this framework do we need to reconsider? 00:29:47.461 --> 00:29:52.101 Once we've done that, we can start thinking about the curriculum, 00:29:52.401 --> 00:29:56.021 how we can backfill a framework with a curriculum. 00:29:56.021 --> 00:30:00.301 Well, of course it won't be one curriculum because curricula exist for different purposes. 00:30:00.521 --> 00:30:07.341 There will be lots of different curricula that we can come to by going through different pathways through the framework. 00:30:08.301 --> 00:30:08.861 Resources. 00:30:10.001 --> 00:30:11.721 Well, goodness me, resources. 00:30:11.901 --> 00:30:14.321 I know Alison and Birgit are going to be talking this afternoon. 00:30:16.301 --> 00:30:16.821 Technology. 00:30:17.101 --> 00:30:21.221 We've talked a little bit about technology already, but technology has quite an impact, 00:30:21.221 --> 00:30:27.721 not only on the way in which we present the content, but also on the way that we construe the content itself. 00:30:28.581 --> 00:30:43.530 So when we looking at resources maybe that going to be something that will change the order in which we look at the content and the order in which we present the content to our students Have we got the right framework Have we got the right model 00:30:45.790 --> 00:30:50.370 Different curriculums for different purposes, and I know that the rest of our speakers are 00:30:50.370 --> 00:30:54.350 going to give us some food for thought on that. We haven't got very far with that in 00:30:54.350 --> 00:30:57.970 our thinking about the framework. It's taken us all our time to think about what the actual 00:30:57.970 --> 00:31:04.130 framework would look like. So, well, what's Cambridge about all of this then? I mean, 00:31:04.130 --> 00:31:10.370 anybody could do this couldn't they um what's cambridge about it well okay we're going to look 00:31:10.370 --> 00:31:13.730 at all of the evidence we're going to look at the research we're going to populate this framework 00:31:13.730 --> 00:31:19.070 whatever it's going to look like but that's not going to be neutral we will be taking a value 00:31:19.070 --> 00:31:24.350 judgment on what we put in there and the value judgment will come from triangulating our judgments 00:31:24.350 --> 00:31:30.630 amongst colleagues within the university not only the four colleagues the four partners that you've 00:31:30.630 --> 00:31:35.910 seen already but other interested people in the university the physicists the social scientists 00:31:35.910 --> 00:31:41.490 the economics economists etc all of those will have a view on what is an appropriate mathematics 00:31:41.490 --> 00:31:47.590 education people in other universities other learned societies and the maths education 00:31:47.590 --> 00:31:54.190 community in general both within the uk and within the international community that we already 00:31:54.190 --> 00:32:00.890 know exists that's an amazing thing to be able to do all of the four partners already have an 00:32:00.890 --> 00:32:08.110 extensive international relationships and so to be able to build on those is going to be a remarkable 00:32:08.110 --> 00:32:16.450 thing to be able to do so we will take a value judgment on what we think are the right elements 00:32:16.557 --> 00:32:21.457 for Cambridge Mathematics in detail and generally. 00:32:23.117 --> 00:32:26.197 One of the first things that we're going to do once we've got the framework 00:32:26.197 --> 00:32:31.917 is we're going to try and populate it with a huge bank of exemplar assessments 00:32:31.917 --> 00:32:36.097 and that's something that we hope that the community will help us to do 00:32:36.097 --> 00:32:39.537 because actually it's the exemplification which really tells the story 00:32:39.537 --> 00:32:44.877 and if we could have a huge bank of assessments which once we put all of the framework etc 00:32:44.877 --> 00:32:47.157 onto some super-duper website, 00:32:47.337 --> 00:32:49.777 which is going to have lots and lots of searching and tagging 00:32:49.777 --> 00:32:51.077 that's available to it, 00:32:51.317 --> 00:32:54.457 then that should be able to become a really fantastic resource 00:32:54.457 --> 00:32:56.817 which will be available for everybody to use. 00:32:58.517 --> 00:33:00.777 So, our goal. 00:33:01.817 --> 00:33:03.177 Blue skies thinking. 00:33:04.237 --> 00:33:07.897 We want the name of Cambridge Mathematics to be associated, 00:33:08.637 --> 00:33:13.437 that it's a guarantee of an evidence-based curriculum and assessment, 00:33:13.437 --> 00:33:18.877 and it's something that is respected both internationally and nationally. 00:33:19.457 --> 00:33:24.117 And it would be fantastic if you'd come along on the journey with us. 00:33:24.517 --> 00:33:25.077 Many thanks. 00:33:31.557 --> 00:33:36.357 So starting that conversation will be Margaret Brown OBE, 00:33:36.877 --> 00:33:40.397 Emeritus Professor of Mathematics Education at King's College London. 00:33:40.397 --> 00:33:46.617 She taught in primary and secondary schools and trained teachers before moving into educational research 00:33:46.617 --> 00:34:02.425 and she directed over 20 research projects related to the learning teaching and assessment of mathematics in all phases of education She been a member of government committees on the mathematics curriculum and assessment and has received the Royal Society Cavalier Medal for contribution 00:34:02.425 --> 00:34:08.045 to research in mathematics education. No better person could start the process. Margaret. 00:34:08.045 --> 00:34:20.045 first of all thank you very much for the kind introduction and for the invitation to speak at 00:34:20.045 --> 00:34:28.086 this really important day I'm hugely supportive of frameworks for mathematics but then hey I'm a 00:34:28.086 --> 00:34:34.886 mathematician so that's the sort of thing I like I love systematizing but I think it one of the 00:34:34.886 --> 00:34:40.986 themes of what I want to say is perhaps that I'm also an educational researcher and I'm aware of 00:34:40.986 --> 00:34:49.766 the fact that although mathematics may be easily classified and divided, people, those that learn 00:34:49.766 --> 00:34:57.645 them, are slightly less easy to systematise. So I think the challenge is to come up with something 00:34:57.645 --> 00:35:04.785 that is truly mathematical and yet which is truly helpful to learners and teachers at all level 00:35:04.785 --> 00:35:14.806 I just want to put a few really some principles and I realized that the first publication I ever 00:35:14.806 --> 00:35:22.666 had was called issues in devising frameworks for mathematics dated 1989 in the first national 00:35:22.666 --> 00:35:30.106 curriculum so one or two of those I'm afraid will go back to those days but I hope that some of those things still 00:35:30.212 --> 00:35:39.452 survive. First of all, I think the important, really important principle about which we know 00:35:39.452 --> 00:35:46.732 is that understanding and connections and indeed mathematical processes or practices, 00:35:46.972 --> 00:35:51.952 whatever we're going to call them, generally progress forward. Children move forward 00:35:51.952 --> 00:35:59.052 in both understanding and practices. Facts and procedures, they don't always move forward. 00:35:59.052 --> 00:36:06.692 And just to show you some examples, this is one that many of you will have seen before. 00:36:07.272 --> 00:36:09.912 This was back in the days of 1986. 00:36:10.592 --> 00:36:16.572 And it's about low attaining year three children's recall of four plus five or five plus three. 00:36:17.052 --> 00:36:23.192 And they previous to this had had five days of teaching, which is session each day, 00:36:23.192 --> 00:36:28.792 simply focusing on those two number bonds, four plus five or five plus three. 00:36:29.052 --> 00:36:37.792 At the end of five days teaching, each of those children along the top could remember at least one of those number bonds, and many of them too. 00:36:38.772 --> 00:36:46.652 They were tested one day later, at which point only two of them could remember one or more, one or two of the bonds. 00:36:46.972 --> 00:36:49.492 One week later, only one could remember. 00:36:49.912 --> 00:36:52.792 Five months later, nobody could remember either of them. 00:36:53.832 --> 00:36:56.652 Ten months later, then progress starts again. 00:36:56.652 --> 00:37:00.572 and 18 months later everyone, all except three children, 00:37:01.372 --> 00:37:18.961 so it not everybody four out of the seven are beginning to move forward So I think we have to remember that mathematics learning doesn always progress that if it learning of facts and algorithms procedures it might quite well move backwards as well 00:37:20.061 --> 00:37:24.281 Another example, I looked up our data on adding fractions. 00:37:24.281 --> 00:37:29.441 The last time we had adding fractions in the primary curriculum, in most schools anyway, 00:37:29.441 --> 00:37:31.221 because it was before national curriculum. 00:37:31.961 --> 00:37:34.201 And we have some interesting results 00:37:34.201 --> 00:37:38.901 on the first two rule-based assessments, I suppose. 00:37:39.641 --> 00:37:42.121 We have 50, the first one a third plus a quarter, 00:37:42.241 --> 00:37:44.841 we have 54% in year seven getting it right, 00:37:45.221 --> 00:37:47.321 and it drops to 38, 35 00:37:47.321 --> 00:37:50.161 before it starts to pick up again in year 10. 00:37:51.301 --> 00:37:55.001 The second one is also in our new primary curriculum. 00:37:55.721 --> 00:37:57.741 And again, we have the same pattern, 00:37:57.741 --> 00:38:04.501 43% in year 7, then really dropping back to 25, 23, 24. 00:38:05.381 --> 00:38:12.401 And those are in contrast to two items that are focusing more on the understanding of fractions, 00:38:12.521 --> 00:38:18.001 which actually provide the basis for understanding the algorithms in the first two examples, 00:38:18.681 --> 00:38:25.161 where children move forward steadily, fairly steadily anyway, from year 7 to year 10. 00:38:25.161 --> 00:38:29.781 but perhaps at a lower level of success than you might expect. 00:38:30.461 --> 00:38:33.861 So the importance I think is what I'm trying to say 00:38:33.861 --> 00:38:38.261 is the kind of interleaving of understanding, 00:38:38.261 --> 00:38:41.181 making connections and of procedures 00:38:41.181 --> 00:38:43.521 that are so important in mathematics. 00:38:43.868 --> 00:38:51.868 Long-term learning, of course, of facts and procedures is also underpinned by that understanding, 00:38:52.468 --> 00:38:56.268 and especially the connections with actions and images. 00:38:56.728 --> 00:39:06.668 And again, a rather old slide, I'm afraid, but one of an evidence-based network on the left of number skills, 00:39:06.808 --> 00:39:10.088 this is going from the bottom of the picture on the left to the top, 00:39:10.088 --> 00:39:16.748 of levels of difficulty, of conceptually based, we called them strategies then, the names change. 00:39:17.628 --> 00:39:24.568 And I think just that it is possible to get a network that most children will conform to. 00:39:24.648 --> 00:39:33.688 All those lines in that first network show patterns of progress that were taken by at least 95% of the children assessed. 00:39:34.528 --> 00:39:39.008 However, it's worth pointing out, the point I made earlier on the right-hand side, 00:39:39.008 --> 00:39:48.228 This is the profile of an actual child who has most of those bottom-level conceptually-based strategies. 00:39:48.928 --> 00:39:54.928 But just to point out, there's one on the far right there that it would appear both logically and psychologically 00:39:54.928 --> 00:40:00.608 that child must have gained in order to move on to the next one, and they still haven't. 00:40:00.608 --> 00:40:10.328 So there are always, I think, some surprises when we come to assess the children or the grown-ups or the adults themselves who are learning mathematics. 00:40:11.848 --> 00:40:32.777 So should our threshold assessment mainly assess understanding and application of key ideas or should it mainly assess facts and procedures or some mixture of the two Can we easily classify questions as testing either facts and procedures 00:40:32.777 --> 00:40:40.777 or understanding or doesn't the balance depend on the state of the learner's knowledge? Is it 00:40:40.777 --> 00:40:49.397 possible to actually know how they've solved the problem. Third principle, developing connections 00:40:49.397 --> 00:40:57.397 takes time. We know this, it's one of the results of our research over many years, and it takes more 00:40:57.397 --> 00:41:04.937 time for some than for others. Armchair curriculum designers, depending on logic rather than empirical 00:41:04.937 --> 00:41:10.837 evidence can have a rose-tinted view, perhaps sometimes a rose-tinted memory of their own 00:41:10.837 --> 00:41:20.377 development, of what students might know and how fast they can learn. In the Cambridge Vice 00:41:20.377 --> 00:41:29.417 Chancellor excerpt we've just said, he pointed out that mathematics is logical and therefore 00:41:29.417 --> 00:41:32.917 it should be easy to use empirical evidence. 00:41:32.917 --> 00:41:36.357 There is, I think, there must be a recognition 00:41:36.357 --> 00:41:39.037 that sometimes the logic diverts 00:41:39.037 --> 00:41:40.477 from the empirical evidence. 00:41:40.477 --> 00:41:43.337 They don't always tell the same story. 00:41:43.337 --> 00:41:46.777 So it's really important that we use, 00:41:46.777 --> 00:41:50.057 everybody said this so far, but I must keep on saying, 00:41:50.057 --> 00:41:52.197 that that empirical evidence is used 00:41:52.197 --> 00:41:54.517 to draw up our framework. 00:41:56.397 --> 00:41:57.417 This is just, 00:41:57.523 --> 00:42:03.663 Again, an old slide showing how children learn. 00:42:03.823 --> 00:42:05.663 And this is going along the bottom. 00:42:05.863 --> 00:42:10.863 You have children in year one, October, June, and so on, up to year six. 00:42:11.123 --> 00:42:17.443 And up the side, you have the success rates for two rather basic parts of the primary curriculum. 00:42:17.643 --> 00:42:22.863 One is about how many apples are there if we have four bags of ten and three loose ones. 00:42:22.863 --> 00:42:28.003 and the other one is what number comes one before 200 in the counting sequence. 00:42:28.583 --> 00:42:33.163 And this is really to show that before it's taught in our primary schools 00:42:33.163 --> 00:42:35.883 there are already 5% of children who can do it. 00:42:36.463 --> 00:42:42.183 But four years after it's taught there are also 5% of children who can't yet do it. 00:42:42.183 --> 00:42:46.603 So the slow growth, and particularly slow for some students, 00:42:47.043 --> 00:42:51.183 has to be taken on board in whatever framework we have. 00:42:52.123 --> 00:42:56.903 This is much more recent data, and this is our ICAMS data. 00:42:57.043 --> 00:43:01.643 It happens to be on place value and decimals in year 7, year 8, and year 9. 00:43:02.163 --> 00:43:05.843 And they show the distribution of children in levels of development. 00:43:06.043 --> 00:43:10.263 Each of those levels can be defined in terms of the skills that children have 00:43:10.263 --> 00:43:14.963 and the understanding children have of place value, particularly in relation to decimals. 00:43:15.583 --> 00:43:18.443 And I think what's so important about that chart 00:43:18.443 --> 00:43:21.703 is how similar the distribution of those levels is 00:43:21.703 --> 00:43:23.583 in year seven, eight and nine. 00:43:23.923 --> 00:43:25.763 There's actually very little progress 00:43:25.763 --> 00:43:28.963 that's made by the average child over that time 00:43:28.963 --> 00:43:46.192 in relation to the huge range of what children can do the huge range of attainment in each of those years So our framework needs to take on board a large range of attainment and also a quite possibly 00:43:46.192 --> 00:43:54.532 quite slow rate of progress. Here's some evidence of what happens when you dream up your curriculum 00:43:54.532 --> 00:44:00.792 from the armchair. This is from the US Common Core now being implemented in most of the states 00:44:00.792 --> 00:44:06.492 in the United States. The first states to do it and to be assessed on it were New York City and 00:44:06.492 --> 00:44:13.872 New York State and the testing began in 2013 and this is a curriculum on the curriculum for grades 00:44:13.872 --> 00:44:20.792 three to eight. Most of the rest of the country will follow their first testing this year. 00:44:20.792 --> 00:44:30.172 in the first testing 30% in New York City 31% in New York State passed maths and that was down 00:44:30.172 --> 00:44:38.552 from 60 to 65% in New York City only 15% of African Americans and 19% of Hispanics passed 00:44:38.552 --> 00:44:46.292 there were nine schools with no passes at all this is just a warning I think about armchair curricula 00:44:46.292 --> 00:44:55.092 so questions can we zoom in to describe empirically small progressive steps which 00:44:55.092 --> 00:45:01.172 lead to greater fluency and applications without leading to an over-detailed and fragmented 00:45:01.172 --> 00:45:05.372 curriculum and this is I think where the technology helps us we now have the zoom 00:45:05.372 --> 00:45:11.052 function so we can have a broader description which zooms into the detail that can pick 00:45:11.179 --> 00:45:16.659 the progress that those children who move quite slowly can make from year to year. 00:45:17.479 --> 00:45:21.539 And the question about how loosely age-related should the framework be. 00:45:22.639 --> 00:45:27.119 I'm not going to say very much about processes, practices, thinking skills, 00:45:27.219 --> 00:45:28.699 whatever we want to talk about them, 00:45:28.979 --> 00:45:33.279 only to note that we've never been terribly successful in frameworks 00:45:33.279 --> 00:45:39.539 with managing to put those in some sort of progression. 00:45:39.539 --> 00:45:45.599 And I guess Malcolm Swan, who's going to talk later, knows at least as much about it as anybody else. 00:45:45.659 --> 00:45:47.379 So I'm really not going to say any more about that. 00:45:48.419 --> 00:45:55.139 But there is a big question about how can progression in problem solving best be described, 00:45:55.379 --> 00:45:59.739 given that the way it progresses is rather different from the content areas. 00:46:00.319 --> 00:46:02.319 I'm just going to add a few minor quibbles. 00:46:02.439 --> 00:46:04.959 It's always tempting to mathematicians to pick up the detail. 00:46:05.619 --> 00:46:07.719 Isn't measurement always about numbers, 00:46:07.799 --> 00:46:09.919 but only sometimes about spatial quantities? 00:46:10.679 --> 00:46:12.459 Isn't logic a branch of maths, 00:46:12.559 --> 00:46:14.139 and not just a mathematical practice? 00:46:14.999 --> 00:46:18.799 And should we be defining our processes, our practices, 00:46:19.379 --> 00:46:22.579 should we be identifying them with the stages of modelling? 00:46:24.599 --> 00:46:28.979 Finally, can we please do what we have been told 00:46:28.979 --> 00:46:33.359 in many of the slides we have seen so far, 00:46:33.359 --> 00:46:39.159 and have a curriculum that really looks forward to the realities of the mid-21st century rather 00:46:39.159 --> 00:46:53.808 than backwards to the 19th whatever they choose to do in Singapore and Shanghai Could I just say that I very pleased to be supporting this movement to the framework I particularly pleased that Lynne is in charge 00:46:54.428 --> 00:46:57.228 I have had the privilege of working with her 00:46:57.228 --> 00:47:00.608 on two frameworks, I think, national frameworks so far, 00:47:01.108 --> 00:47:05.888 one of which, sadly, never quite made it to the statute books, 00:47:06.248 --> 00:47:07.948 and one of which, sadly, did. 00:47:08.508 --> 00:47:09.108 Thank you. 00:47:09.108 --> 00:47:10.588 APPLAUSE 00:47:10.588 --> 00:47:12.848 Thank you. 00:47:17.848 --> 00:47:21.708 Well, thank you very much indeed, Margaret and Lynne. 00:47:22.208 --> 00:47:24.648 And now, over to you. 00:47:25.088 --> 00:47:29.648 As I said before, questions, comments, 00:47:31.828 --> 00:47:36.048 you can encapsulate a paper you wrote a year ago, 00:47:36.588 --> 00:47:37.928 anything you like. 00:47:37.928 --> 00:47:40.548 So if you'd like to start putting your hands up now. 00:47:41.528 --> 00:47:44.328 The one thing that struck me was, 00:47:46.088 --> 00:47:51.888 and this may be the fault of Margaret looking back perhaps too much, 00:47:52.028 --> 00:47:54.708 but it occurred to me, the number of slides you had, 00:47:54.788 --> 00:47:57.688 which seemed to be repeating old truths. 00:47:57.808 --> 00:48:00.848 It looked a little bit, and I looked to the audience here, 00:48:01.408 --> 00:48:04.248 it looked a little bit that the more we go back, 00:48:04.908 --> 00:48:06.648 the further forwards we progress. 00:48:06.648 --> 00:48:09.728 That was just something that came out for me. 00:48:09.728 --> 00:48:12.928 Are we rediscovering old truths or are we breaking new ground? 00:48:12.928 --> 00:48:15.568 That's a question for the audience. 00:48:15.568 --> 00:48:21.008 But we've actually got the British International College. 00:48:21.008 --> 00:48:24.708 Andrew Mutera has sent through a... 00:48:24.835 --> 00:48:30.715 has sent through a question for everybody, really, 00:48:31.115 --> 00:48:36.075 which is, converting a word problem into a mathematical equation 00:48:36.075 --> 00:48:38.975 should be a skill introduced progressively 00:48:38.975 --> 00:48:41.695 as the level of knowledge becomes detailed. 00:48:42.595 --> 00:48:45.195 How much do we agree or disagree with this? 00:48:45.235 --> 00:48:47.755 There's another question for you, and Margaret's already given us four. 00:48:49.175 --> 00:48:52.695 And Steve Watson on Twitter has said, 00:48:52.695 --> 00:48:57.855 the starting point may be assessment but of equal importance is pedagogy understanding pedagogy and 00:48:57.855 --> 00:49:03.415 how it might be developed is the key well we're going to tackle pedagogy a little later on um so 00:49:03.415 --> 00:49:10.615 we'll stay with the with the framework for the moment um so we'll come back to that in the meantime 00:49:10.615 --> 00:49:18.695 that gentleman at the back there is going to open the discussion for us i hadn't realized i was at 00:49:18.695 --> 00:49:26.455 the back. My name's Dan Thomas. I work for CCSS, an independent sixth form college in Cambridge. 00:49:28.555 --> 00:49:34.535 I guess I'm adding a question rather than answering one. I find it immensely reassuring 00:49:34.535 --> 00:49:42.335 the level of expertise that you have collaborated with and that's in this room. We've got educators, 00:49:42.335 --> 00:49:48.775 educators, educational researchers, academic mathematicians, and it's great that all these 00:49:48.775 --> 00:49:51.215 people are feeding into the framework process. 00:49:51.215 --> 00:49:56.235 I guess my question comes back to one of the slides that you showed earlier, which was 00:49:56.235 --> 00:50:11.704 the different views of what mathematics education should be something I ask my students if I feeling brave and something I think about myself quite a lot And it seems to me the group that wasn mentioned is industry 00:50:12.624 --> 00:50:15.144 I've done quite a lot of CPD with MEI 00:50:15.144 --> 00:50:21.124 and my own focus is more on the applied modules in the A-level 00:50:21.124 --> 00:50:22.664 than the pure perhaps. 00:50:22.664 --> 00:50:31.324 so for me it's important that my students are going somewhere with this that they're 00:50:31.324 --> 00:50:37.164 learning things that are going to be useful for them both in academia but also if they 00:50:37.164 --> 00:50:41.284 choose to go a different route something that they're going to be able to apply 00:50:41.284 --> 00:50:48.104 in industry is there any collaboration taking place in that direction i guess is my question 00:50:48.104 --> 00:50:51.764 which i think is a question that you should perhaps address 00:50:51.764 --> 00:51:02.844 so um when i indicated the uh five different groups which had different aims i did mention 00:51:02.844 --> 00:51:09.644 i think i called them the technical pragmatists um those who think that industry that that having 00:51:09.644 --> 00:51:15.604 skills ready to be used in industry is very important and you're absolutely right that uh 00:51:15.604 --> 00:51:21.164 we need to consult with not only people in academe but we need to consult with others so 00:51:21.164 --> 00:51:27.604 So for example, one of the things that we might want to look at is what mathematical 00:51:27.604 --> 00:51:34.544 skills, processes, knowledge do learners need if they're going to start an apprenticeship 00:51:34.544 --> 00:51:36.244 in some particular area. 00:51:36.244 --> 00:51:38.384 Well, I would say that. 00:51:38.490 --> 00:51:44.850 know, but there are people who do. So one would have to, and one would want to consult 00:51:44.850 --> 00:51:50.630 with the community on that. And that's, of course, why it's going to take five years, 00:51:50.810 --> 00:51:57.230 at least, because there are a vast number of different constituencies out there that 00:51:57.230 --> 00:52:01.790 we would want to make sure, in order to get buy-in, we need to make sure that we consult 00:52:01.790 --> 00:52:05.290 and listen to them. I don't know if you want to add anything to it. 00:52:05.290 --> 00:52:11.730 so lynn what i don't quite get there is um presumably the framework is actually going to be 00:52:11.730 --> 00:52:18.550 um a spine which as it were defines maths as far as that's definable um but what that gentleman was 00:52:18.550 --> 00:52:25.390 talking about is actually going to be a curriculum takeout from the framework so do you actually need 00:52:25.390 --> 00:52:31.710 to consult industry at this point about the type of framework or do you need to go to industry later 00:52:31.710 --> 00:52:33.750 to say, right, now let's talk about... 00:52:33.750 --> 00:52:36.150 Well, we'd need to make sure that industry has a view 00:52:36.150 --> 00:52:37.970 on what should be in the framework, 00:52:38.690 --> 00:52:41.750 but then the thing that will distinguish the curriculum 00:52:41.750 --> 00:52:43.850 that might be appropriate, for example, 00:52:44.050 --> 00:52:46.070 for the person who's going to be an apprentice, 00:52:46.350 --> 00:52:49.370 to do an apprentice, would be the path through that framework. 00:52:50.150 --> 00:52:54.390 And we would then want to look and ask different constituencies 00:52:54.390 --> 00:52:57.530 what would be an appropriate path through the framework. 00:52:57.670 --> 00:52:59.490 There are lots of big areas of the framework 00:52:59.490 --> 00:53:01.530 that would not be appropriate for certain people 00:53:01.530 --> 00:53:04.310 to be able to study, but others that needed a greater focus. 00:53:04.990 --> 00:53:08.350 So the framework, in essence, will be the totality, 00:53:08.890 --> 00:53:25.939 but there will be different pathways through it Does that answer your question Ish Yeah I think my initial concern with all of these is I think everybody should be studying mathematics 00:53:25.939 --> 00:53:33.599 I think mathematics is incredibly valuable as a language, as a means of describing the world around us, 00:53:33.719 --> 00:53:37.819 and a means of systematising and ways of thinking. 00:53:40.339 --> 00:53:50.079 So on the one hand, I've got this fairly, I don't know, progressive, idealistic view that everybody should be studying mathematics. 00:53:50.559 --> 00:53:58.699 And then I sit in my classroom with the student who's going to be lucky to come out with a U in A-level maths because their parents have decided that they should be doing maths. 00:53:59.479 --> 00:54:03.019 And I sit and try and reconcile these two views. 00:54:03.019 --> 00:54:11.839 and I think what you're saying that you know the the framework is there and the path in which the 00:54:11.839 --> 00:54:19.779 student treads may well be different um yeah it it goes it reassures me that the question is being 00:54:19.779 --> 00:54:25.899 thought about and I don't necessarily think you should have an answer yet 00:54:25.899 --> 00:54:36.219 Could I just add one thing to that which is that I sort of gave a sort of simplistic 00:54:36.219 --> 00:54:42.879 view of the framework being through the content, the path being through the content. The content 00:54:42.879 --> 00:54:47.659 is only a two dimensional thing, we've got all these other dimensions behind it so actually 00:54:47.659 --> 00:54:52.039 the path through the framework will not only be through the content but it might also be in the 00:54:52.146 --> 00:54:56.226 problem-solving skills that are needed and the depth of conceptual understanding that will be 00:54:56.226 --> 00:55:04.546 needed so it's not just the content right um can i move to south africa i think south africa have 00:55:04.546 --> 00:55:12.626 a question from graham evans head of mass at st john's college is he online yeah i'm here 00:55:12.626 --> 00:55:14.626 Graham 00:55:14.626 --> 00:55:16.386 Yeah 00:55:16.386 --> 00:55:18.546 I really like the idea 00:55:18.546 --> 00:55:20.546 that 00:55:20.546 --> 00:55:22.106 Lynn alluded to of 00:55:22.106 --> 00:55:24.846 the idea of maths appreciation 00:55:24.846 --> 00:55:26.486 well she spoke of maths appreciation 00:55:26.486 --> 00:55:28.746 versus the utility of maths 00:55:28.746 --> 00:55:30.626 and I was just wondering whether that is 00:55:30.626 --> 00:55:32.366 something that we could build into assessments 00:55:32.366 --> 00:55:34.666 just the appreciation 00:55:34.666 --> 00:55:35.666 of what they're doing 00:55:35.666 --> 00:55:42.606 And actually I'm going to point at Tim Rowland 00:55:42.606 --> 00:55:48.226 because Tim has just edited a fantastic book in which Paul has a chapter. 00:55:49.006 --> 00:55:50.346 Tim, can I throw it to you? 00:55:50.886 --> 00:55:54.246 Because it's a very interesting idea, isn't it, 00:55:54.246 --> 00:55:57.726 to completely reconceptualise what the content of mathematics is 00:55:57.726 --> 00:56:03.126 into this whole idea of capability being the stuff that you need to know, 00:56:03.366 --> 00:56:05.566 but then the appreciation being, I think, 00:56:05.626 --> 00:56:08.026 what a lot of us think is what gives maths its richness. 00:56:09.046 --> 00:56:11.086 Tim Rowland, University of Cambridge. 00:56:11.626 --> 00:56:12.786 I'll sit down at this point. 00:56:13.886 --> 00:56:18.686 This feels like a test, Lynn, as to whether I know the content of the chapters in the book that I edited. 00:56:21.906 --> 00:56:22.766 Yes, certainly. 00:56:22.846 --> 00:56:35.455 Because the cameras have to catch you for the worldwide audience Certainly I mean I think this question about competence against appreciation is one that has been a missed opportunity 00:56:35.455 --> 00:56:45.435 in the the new core mathematics post 16 and frankly that not just in in the 00:56:45.435 --> 00:56:49.075 it's particularly true in the modern world but I think it's always been true 00:56:49.075 --> 00:56:56.275 that there's mathematics that we need to know in order to be able to do things, 00:56:56.275 --> 00:57:00.595 not least to pass mathematics exams, but also to be numerous citizens. 00:57:01.595 --> 00:57:06.115 But there's, if you like, a kind of cultural dimension to mathematics 00:57:06.115 --> 00:57:15.835 in that we live in a world in which there are and have been amazing mathematical achievements 00:57:15.835 --> 00:57:20.295 which are accessible to the ordinary person 00:57:20.295 --> 00:57:27.135 without detailed knowledge of the intricate details of it. 00:57:27.695 --> 00:57:31.315 And I would include in this, I mean, 00:57:31.835 --> 00:57:35.895 not just things like chaos theory and the like 00:57:35.895 --> 00:57:42.975 and the kind of design of digital innovations and so on, 00:57:42.975 --> 00:57:47.835 but also historical aspects of the way mathematics has evolved over time. 00:57:47.835 --> 00:57:53.775 And I mean one could liken it, it's a very crude distinction, 00:57:53.775 --> 00:57:58.815 the distinction between English language and English literature. 00:57:58.815 --> 00:58:05.695 In the second one is engaging in a kind of 00:58:05.802 --> 00:58:10.202 cultural dimension. 00:58:11.062 --> 00:58:12.542 So, I mean, I would... 00:58:12.542 --> 00:58:15.262 I was noted your comment on that, Lynn, 00:58:15.322 --> 00:58:18.702 and would think it would be very profitable 00:58:18.702 --> 00:58:21.922 to explore this appreciation side, 00:58:22.002 --> 00:58:23.862 because until now it hasn't really happened. 00:58:25.342 --> 00:58:26.742 Could I add something to that? 00:58:27.302 --> 00:58:29.702 Of course, that's one of the fantastic things 00:58:29.702 --> 00:58:32.382 about the maths faculty being part of this partnership, 00:58:32.662 --> 00:58:35.482 is that if we're considering what mathematics 00:58:35.482 --> 00:58:37.882 we want to hand on to the next generation, 00:58:38.462 --> 00:58:41.202 then actually having the mathematics faculty on board 00:58:41.202 --> 00:58:42.862 is really, really important. 00:58:45.282 --> 00:58:48.522 Now, Egypt have a number of points to make, 00:58:48.602 --> 00:58:50.782 so we've just moved to Egypt first 00:58:50.782 --> 00:58:53.162 and then come to the middle there. 00:58:54.382 --> 00:58:54.942 Egypt? 00:58:55.962 --> 00:58:58.102 You had a number of points? 00:59:00.102 --> 00:59:01.142 Yeah, I've got more. 00:59:01.742 --> 00:59:01.942 Yeah. 00:59:02.942 --> 00:59:03.802 Which question? 00:59:05.482 --> 00:59:06.782 Can we ask? 00:59:07.122 --> 00:59:07.922 Yes, yes. 00:59:07.922 --> 00:59:08.842 Go ahead. 00:59:15.222 --> 00:59:17.582 We don't stick necessarily to the questions. 00:59:18.522 --> 00:59:22.382 Make the points you want to make, but also with questions as well. 00:59:22.682 --> 00:59:22.822 Okay? 00:59:26.162 --> 00:59:31.382 Sometimes the wording of the question is very difficult for the international students to understand 00:59:31.382 --> 00:59:34.582 for the extended syllabus, code 0580. 00:59:35.482 --> 00:59:49.651 I talking about the wording of the question I think that a specific question about one of Cambridge International qualifications 00:59:49.651 --> 00:59:55.651 but the general point is that for international students whose first language is not English, 00:59:55.651 --> 01:00:03.651 the way the question is written can be a factor, not just the mathematical content of the assessment. 01:00:03.651 --> 01:00:10.311 which presumably impacts on what Tim's just been saying about appreciation. 01:00:11.311 --> 01:00:15.651 Appreciation is going to be much more about talking about maths 01:00:15.651 --> 01:00:18.991 rather than actually doing the practical application of maths. 01:00:19.051 --> 01:00:19.551 Is that right? 01:00:19.971 --> 01:00:22.631 In which case, as you then talk to an international audience, 01:00:23.371 --> 01:00:29.031 you'll be landing whole ideas in different cultural contexts, 01:00:29.571 --> 01:00:31.931 so they may actually end up being something else. 01:00:33.651 --> 01:00:34.531 Does that make sense? 01:00:35.171 --> 01:00:35.731 Are you asking me? 01:00:35.731 --> 01:00:37.131 Yes, I'm asking you. 01:00:37.131 --> 01:00:37.311 Sorry. 01:00:39.711 --> 01:00:43.991 I mean, of course that's right. 01:00:44.371 --> 01:00:49.471 But I don't think this is a problem peculiar to mathematics at all. 01:00:49.691 --> 01:00:55.951 I mean, the business of communicating between peoples in different countries 01:00:55.951 --> 01:01:02.111 with different linguistic backgrounds is not peculiar to mathematics. 01:01:02.111 --> 01:01:11.271 and I don't see it as being different in the case of mathematics appreciation. 01:01:14.271 --> 01:01:16.311 So, Tony in the middle. 01:01:19.457 --> 01:01:23.457 Tony Gardner, mathematician. 01:01:23.457 --> 01:01:31.457 It's very difficult not to just welcome a positive development, 01:01:31.457 --> 01:01:35.457 but so far I'm scared. 01:01:35.457 --> 01:01:39.457 And I hope you haven't got past the stage of recognizing 01:01:39.457 --> 01:01:43.457 that progress often involves screwing up the piece of paper 01:01:43.457 --> 01:01:47.457 and starting again. 01:01:47.457 --> 01:02:00.637 It's when you get old, you have to get used to watching what is actually valuable progress, but wrongheaded, perhaps. 01:02:01.457 --> 01:02:07.677 Understanding, application, appreciation, problem solving. 01:02:08.457 --> 01:02:11.057 These are all wonderful things. 01:02:11.057 --> 01:02:18.957 and they motivated everything I have tried to do from the beginning. 01:02:19.597 --> 01:02:25.877 However, assessment even motivates all sorts of people, 01:02:26.437 --> 01:02:29.717 but they're the wrong place to start. 01:02:29.717 --> 01:02:38.137 Please, mathematics is, I'm afraid, about facts and procedures 01:02:38.137 --> 01:02:49.657 through which you begin to appreciate, to understand, and to solve problems. So please consider 01:02:49.657 --> 01:03:01.866 content may actually be the key It the way you approach content the way you present and assess facts and procedures 01:03:02.666 --> 01:03:04.286 not the things themselves. 01:03:04.426 --> 01:03:06.606 Facts, procedures, content may be the key. 01:03:08.366 --> 01:03:11.106 I think I should stop there before I say something. 01:03:13.906 --> 01:03:15.346 It's woken them up at the back. 01:03:15.946 --> 01:03:17.566 Do you want to take the first of that, 01:03:17.626 --> 01:03:19.546 and then I'm going to ask everybody else, 01:03:19.666 --> 01:03:21.106 what do people think about that? 01:03:21.306 --> 01:03:22.746 I think that's a fair point to make. 01:03:23.266 --> 01:03:23.486 Yes. 01:03:24.526 --> 01:03:26.906 I think it's fantastic that you're here, Tony, 01:03:27.046 --> 01:03:28.846 and your humane curriculum... 01:03:28.846 --> 01:03:29.026 I did. 01:03:34.026 --> 01:03:37.146 I didn't mean it in that sense, honest. 01:03:38.146 --> 01:03:43.466 But your humane curriculum is a fantastic piece of work, 01:03:43.466 --> 01:03:49.406 and I suppose one of my challenges is 01:03:49.406 --> 01:03:58.026 trying to take the best of things without destroying the integrity of each. 01:03:58.586 --> 01:04:01.186 And I think that's a really interesting challenge 01:04:01.186 --> 01:04:04.706 and one which I'd love to have you alongside. 01:04:05.946 --> 01:04:08.006 Are you not in danger of making a dog's breakfast 01:04:08.006 --> 01:04:11.986 if you're going to take a bit of this, a bit of that, a bit of that? 01:04:12.066 --> 01:04:13.606 That's exactly the issue. 01:04:14.546 --> 01:04:14.866 Right. 01:04:15.806 --> 01:04:19.006 I'm slightly surprised we haven't heard from pure mathematicians. 01:04:19.406 --> 01:04:22.406 because so far we've been, apart from... 01:04:22.406 --> 01:04:23.406 Mark groups. 01:04:23.406 --> 01:04:28.406 Well, we seem to be very utilitarian to date. 01:04:28.406 --> 01:04:33.006 You know, about practicalities, facilities, applications, 01:04:33.113 --> 01:04:37.113 and all the rest of it, we don't seem to have had anybody coming out 01:04:37.113 --> 01:04:42.253 and pointing that we need to move much wider than that utilitarian approach. 01:04:43.253 --> 01:04:44.453 Or perhaps I haven't been listening. 01:04:46.453 --> 01:04:48.153 What would you say, Lynne? 01:04:50.433 --> 01:04:52.133 Well, Tony's a mathematician. 01:04:53.653 --> 01:04:54.573 He's a pure mathematician. 01:04:54.833 --> 01:04:55.393 Everybody's a mathematician. 01:04:56.293 --> 01:05:00.993 So I'm not totally quite sure. 01:05:01.113 --> 01:05:02.833 I think we've got a good balance so far. 01:05:03.113 --> 01:05:06.413 Just wondering whether we're in a good balance of input. 01:05:06.413 --> 01:05:07.253 Yes, yes. 01:05:08.273 --> 01:05:13.153 Right, South Africa has a question. 01:05:13.973 --> 01:05:16.533 I will repeat what I said at the beginning. 01:05:16.653 --> 01:05:19.033 This is less about questions, more about you telling us what to do, 01:05:19.233 --> 01:05:20.573 which is why I quite like Tony's. 01:05:21.093 --> 01:05:21.993 Right, South Africa. 01:05:23.913 --> 01:05:25.013 That's Graham again. 01:05:27.693 --> 01:05:28.593 Thanks very much. 01:05:29.253 --> 01:05:31.593 This might upset Tony, I'm not sure. 01:05:32.593 --> 01:05:35.353 But there's quite a lot of debate in South Africa. 01:05:35.453 --> 01:05:44.073 I'm sure there's a lot of debate in the UK and around the world about the use of calculators in school and to what extent they can be used in exams and that kind of thing. 01:05:46.133 --> 01:05:55.913 And I think it was Margaret who made a comment that made me think of perhaps because calculators can do a lot more than they used to be able to do, 01:05:55.913 --> 01:05:59.513 perhaps they can take care of the routine and the knowledge 01:05:59.513 --> 01:06:02.733 and perhaps assessments should focus more on the understanding 01:06:02.733 --> 01:06:04.833 and the application and the problem solving, 01:06:05.513 --> 01:06:16.642 utilising the technology at our disposal Which goes a lot wider than just calculators of course Can I come in and try and respond to that 01:06:16.642 --> 01:06:23.602 I think it's certainly the case that any curriculum that we want to specify 01:06:23.602 --> 01:06:28.862 must take account of the technology that we have and how it will be used. 01:06:29.542 --> 01:06:37.622 But in a sense, it's also important that people can interpret the answers from the technology 01:06:37.622 --> 01:06:41.962 and can set up its use and know broadly what's going on. 01:06:41.962 --> 01:06:51.842 So I think that to sort of regard that something is happening in a black box that you don't need to understand 01:06:51.842 --> 01:06:54.142 is often not a good response. 01:06:54.802 --> 01:07:05.602 What we probably need to do is to say that we need more and more to have an understanding of what it is that calculators and computers are doing in a broad sense. 01:07:05.602 --> 01:07:13.242 But there's certainly no point becoming efficient in procedures that can be more efficiently done elsewhere. 01:07:14.102 --> 01:07:16.362 So it's not quite, I think, a black and white. 01:07:16.502 --> 01:07:21.442 I think it's knowing enough to be able to use the technology effectively. 01:07:21.442 --> 01:07:27.602 Is that an age question as well? You've got to know enough of the procedures before you 01:07:27.602 --> 01:07:36.722 start moving on to using the technology. So in a framework, would we be likely to say, 01:07:36.722 --> 01:07:40.562 no technology before X? Or would that be overly... 01:07:40.562 --> 01:07:46.662 Well, I think they develop together. I mean, the one-year-old child already has 01:07:46.769 --> 01:07:55.069 access to the tablet. And children know what's available. You can't fool them that they actually 01:07:55.069 --> 01:08:03.989 have to learn procedures that they don't have to learn. So I think we must work in the world we 01:08:03.989 --> 01:08:11.169 have. And in particular, I think one of the things it does suggest is that we start introducing 01:08:11.169 --> 01:08:18.229 ideas at a younger age in the sense that we can start thinking about how what is happening 01:08:18.229 --> 01:08:24.289 on a tablet that's quite sophisticated and trying to translate that into something that 01:08:24.289 --> 01:08:26.369 can be understood by quite young children. 01:08:26.929 --> 01:08:34.789 So sometimes I think it means pulling some of the ideas down the age range as well as 01:08:34.789 --> 01:08:36.529 maybe pushing some of them up. 01:08:36.529 --> 01:08:44.069 There's one here and one two rows back. 01:08:44.149 --> 01:08:45.049 Did you have your hand up, sir? 01:08:45.329 --> 01:08:45.909 No? Okay. 01:08:46.149 --> 01:08:47.429 And the gentleman at the back there. 01:08:49.829 --> 01:08:52.849 Sue Gifford, University of Roehampton and ACME. 01:08:53.629 --> 01:08:54.929 Two requests. 01:08:55.129 --> 01:08:58.769 One is, can you get a designer with worse eyesight, please, 01:08:58.889 --> 01:09:01.889 so that we can actually read what's written on the framework? 01:09:01.889 --> 01:09:11.649 work. Fantastic. The other thing is the BSRLM, the British Society of Research and Learning 01:09:11.649 --> 01:09:18.129 Maths, was in Dublin looking at the Irish review that precedes their curriculum for 328. So 01:09:18.129 --> 01:09:33.478 they identify one of the challenges is to integrate processes and content in a curriculum And I think that is the request especially looking at the dislocation between the aims of the current curriculum and the content 01:09:34.398 --> 01:09:38.618 So if it's possible to put those assessment tasks and thresholds 01:09:39.318 --> 01:09:45.438 as in terms of reasoning and understanding, the ability to explain and to use, 01:09:45.438 --> 01:09:48.098 and I think that includes the appreciation. 01:09:48.618 --> 01:09:51.258 to not have those separate. 01:09:51.758 --> 01:09:53.118 So that's my request. 01:09:54.078 --> 01:09:57.398 So at the moment, the model is that that is another dimension. 01:09:57.658 --> 01:09:59.538 So when you're looking at the content, 01:09:59.538 --> 01:10:04.858 you can look at it through a lens of those different processes. 01:10:05.938 --> 01:10:08.118 So we're going to go to the final question. 01:10:08.378 --> 01:10:09.238 It's there at the back. 01:10:10.578 --> 01:10:11.218 Gentleman. 01:10:11.498 --> 01:10:12.178 Yes, that's it. 01:10:12.178 --> 01:10:19.538 Hello, I'm Charlie Strip from MEI and NCTM. 01:10:20.038 --> 01:10:24.958 I wonder whether developing efficient knowledge and procedures for basic arithmetic algebra 01:10:24.958 --> 01:10:27.578 might actually be essential to being able to develop understanding in mathematics. 01:10:28.238 --> 01:10:29.858 Perhaps we should do some research to find out, 01:10:29.938 --> 01:10:33.398 because I'm a bit wary of the idea that you can not bother with these efficient procedures 01:10:33.398 --> 01:10:36.498 because somehow you don't need them anymore because the machines will do it for you. 01:10:36.798 --> 01:10:40.418 I suspect that they might be key to developing deep mathematical understanding, 01:10:40.418 --> 01:10:42.658 and I don't know the answer to that so let's find out. 01:10:42.658 --> 01:10:47.058 Yeah, could I just respond? 01:10:47.058 --> 01:10:52.758 One of the first things I did in secondary school was to be taught the pencil and paper 01:10:52.758 --> 01:10:58.738 method for extracting square roots and I found it almost impossible to remember this because 01:10:58.738 --> 01:11:00.318 I hadn't a clue why it worked. 01:11:00.424 --> 01:11:03.324 and I decided I really couldn't be very good at maths. 01:11:04.644 --> 01:11:08.384 I've met lots of adults who decided very early 01:11:08.384 --> 01:11:09.604 that they couldn't be good at maths 01:11:09.604 --> 01:11:11.964 because they couldn't understand and remember 01:11:11.964 --> 01:11:15.404 how to add fractions or how to do long division. 01:11:16.444 --> 01:11:20.884 I think we have to evaluate what we're getting from... 01:11:20.884 --> 01:11:23.324 I mean, there are many children, probably the majority, 01:11:23.984 --> 01:11:27.684 who enjoy doing long division and can get something from it. 01:11:27.684 --> 01:11:41.524 But I think we have to look very hard at saying, we only have a limited time in the curriculum, whether it's adult education or school education or university education. 01:11:41.844 --> 01:11:45.664 We have to prioritise what we're doing in that period. 01:11:46.304 --> 01:11:53.204 And we have to look, I think, very carefully at all aspects of maths and say, is this really worthwhile? 01:11:53.204 --> 01:11:57.724 Right, we're running up to the coffee break. 01:11:57.864 --> 01:11:58.444 We finally... 01:11:58.444 --> 01:11:59.904 Oh, okay, respond, sir. 01:11:59.964 --> 01:12:00.764 You have just enough time. 01:12:00.784 --> 01:12:02.844 I think the square root algorithm is a caricature. 01:12:02.964 --> 01:12:04.884 Nobody would advocate teaching that. 01:12:05.184 --> 01:12:06.364 But I think that... 01:12:06.364 --> 01:12:09.104 They don't want to advocate teaching long division. 01:12:09.564 --> 01:12:12.524 But there are many other algorithms where if they're taught... 01:12:12.524 --> 01:12:14.164 I think you're crystallising the way they've been taught 01:12:14.164 --> 01:12:16.924 rather than their value in terms of learning, perhaps. 01:12:17.284 --> 01:12:18.384 We need to research this. 01:12:18.724 --> 01:12:21.924 But I think the square root algorithm is an easy one to pick on. 01:12:21.924 --> 01:12:25.164 perhaps some long multiplication might not be such an easy one to criticise. 01:12:25.264 --> 01:12:26.024 I agree. 01:12:27.104 --> 01:12:31.844 Right, so just as it was breaking out, time for a coffee break. 01:12:32.284 --> 01:12:44.533 We given quite a long time for a coffee break in this event because everybody kept telling us they wanted more time to talk to each other and to think up killer questions and killer points to make 01:12:45.593 --> 01:12:48.873 So back here at, I believe, is 11.45. 01:12:51.973 --> 01:12:55.973 And I'm hoping that the next session will be on professional development. 01:12:56.593 --> 01:13:00.293 So discuss, talk, and come back refreshed and full of caffeine. 01:13:00.633 --> 01:13:01.013 Thank you. 01:13:02.273 --> 01:13:32.253 Thank you. 01:13:32.273 --> 01:14:02.253 Thank you. 01:14:02.273 --> 01:14:13.953 Thank you.